2008
November: Terrance Zdunich
October: Ryan "Rotten" Turek
September: Zack Ward
August: Michael Pare
July: Mark Hengst
June: Kim Sonderholm
May: Connor Ross
April: Steve Wozniak
March: Robert Rhine
February: Sam Witwer
January: Darrin Ramage

2007
December: Connor Ross (Scary Stud of the year!)
November: Jimmy Hemphill
October: Andre Gower
September: Kirk "Sticky Fingaz" Jones
August: Adam Green
July: Don Mancini
June: Brian Pulido
May: Eric Stanze
April: Danny Lopes
March: Christopher Garetano
February: Paul Solet
January: Eric Spudic

2006
December: Cory Knauf
November: Casper Van Dien
October: Jake Busey
September: Travis Betz
August: Dante Tomaselli
July: Trent Haaga
June: Jeff Dylan Graham
May: Joe Zaso
April: David Heavener
March: Tim Sullivan (Scary Stud of the year!)
February: Spooky Dan
January: Jay Hernandez

2005
December: Ford Austin
November: Scott Whyte
October: DJ Perry
September: Christopher Atkins
August: Peter and Michael Spierig
July: Bill Moseley
June :Todd Livingston
May:Rob Monkiewicz
April: Robert Rodriguez
March: Joe Bob Briggs
February: Bruce Campbell
January: John Fallon

2004
November: Ryan Reynolds
October: Ken Foree